 | 1. | Current General Hospital Site, St Helier | Shortlisted in 2012 and 2014. | - Preferred site – find out more here
|
 | 2. | Overdale Hospital, St Helier | Shortlisted in 2012 and 2014. | - Constrained site compromises hospital design.
- Poor public and emergency access.
- Visual and local environmental impact.
- Limited opportunity for future expansion.
|
 | 3. | St Saviour’s Hospital, St Saviour | Long-listed in 2012. | - Poor access for the majority of the Island’s Population and staff.
- Planning restrictions would severely compromise clinical functionality.
- Major Infrastructure would be required (roads and drains).
|
 | 4. | Waterfront (Esplanade Car Park), St Helier | Screened out in 2012. | - Constrained site compromises hospital design.
- Requires flood protection measures.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
 | 5. | Former D’Hautree School Site, St Saviour | Screened out in 2012. | - An eight storey building would be required – unsuitable to the site setting.
- Relocation of functions would be problematic within 3-5 years.
|
 | 6. | Former Jersey College for Girls, St Helier | Screened out in 2012. | - The site footprint is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- Relocation of functions would be problematic within 3-5 years
|
 | 7. | States Offices, South Hill, St Helier | Screened out in 2012. | - The site footprint is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- A seven storey building would be required – unsuitable to the site setting.
|
|
 | 8. | Fields South of Airport (47,48, 22, 24 – 27), St Peter | Longlisted in 2012. | - Major Infrastructure would be required (fuel depot and drainage).
- Poor access for the majority of the Island’s Population.
- Environmental and safety issues.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
|
 | 9. | Summerland/Ambulance Station, St Helier | Screened out in 2012. | - The site footprint is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- A very large building of 7 – 8 storeys would be unsuitable to the site setting.
- Relocation of functions would be problematic within 3-5 years.
|
|
 | 10. | Warwick Farm, St Helier | Short-listed in 2012. | - Poor public and emergency access.
- Visual and local environmental impact would be out of keeping with surroundings.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
|
 | 11. | Fort Regent, St Helier | Screened out in 2012. | - Infrastructure and access restrictions.
- The topology is not suitable for a hospital.
- Significant heritage issues.
- Relocation of functions would be problematic within 3-5 years
|
|
 | 12. | Snow Hill Car Park, St Helier | Screened out in 2012. | - The site footprint is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- A fourteen storey building would be required – unsuitable to the site setting.
|
|
 | 13. | Elizabeth Harbour, St Helier | Screened out in 2012. | - Relocation of functions would be problematic within 3-5 years.
|
|
 | 14. | Waterfront (Zephyrus/former Crosslands/Les Jardin de la Mer), St Helier | Shortlisted in 2012 and 2014. | - Constrained site compromises hospital design.
- Requires flood protection measures.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
|
 | 15. | Bellozanne Valley, St Helier | Screened out in 2012. | - The site footprint is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- Relocation of functions would be problematic within 3-5 years.
|
|
 | 16. | Jersey Gas Site, Tunnell St, St Helier | Longlisted in 2012. | - The site footprint is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- A twelve storey building would be required – unsuitable to the site setting.
|
|
 | 17. | Le Masurier’s Land, Bath St, St Helier | Screened out in 2012. | - The site footprint is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- A twelve storey building would be required – unsuitable to the site setting.
|
|
 | 18. | Former Jersey Brewery, Ann St, St Helier | Screened out in 2012. | - The site footprint is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- A twelve storey building would be required – unsuitable to the site setting.
|
|
 | 19. | Westmount Quarry, St Helier | Longlisted in 2012. | - The site footprint is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- The topography is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- Ownership and use means availability would be problematic within 3-5 years.
|
|
 | 20. | Longueville Nurseries, St Saviour | Screened out in 2012. | - The site footprint is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- Significant transport and access issues.
|
|
 | 21. | Samares Nurseries, St Clement | Longlisted in 2012. | - Significant transport and access issues.
- Major infrastructure required (roads and water supply).
- Clinical design and future flexibility concerns.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
|
 | 22. | Field 1219, Grande Route De Mont a L’Abbe, St Helier | Longlisted in 2012. | - The site footprint is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- Significant transport and access issues exist.
|
|
 | 23. | Field H1550, Westmount, St Helier | Longlisted with Site 2 and 24 in 2012. | - Significant transport and access issues exist.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
|
 | 24. | Field H1551. Westmount, St Helier | Longlisted with Site 2 and 23 in 2012. | - Significant transport and access issues exist.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
|
 | 25. | Parade Gardens, St Helier | Screened out in 2012 and 2015. | - The site footprint is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- A covenant on the site prohibits building.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
|
 | 26. | Springfield Stadium, St Helier | Screened out in 2012. | - Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
- Relocation of functions would be problematic within 3-5 years.
|
|
 | 27. | FB Fields, St Clement | Screened out in 2012. | - A covenant prohibits building on the site.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
- Relocation of functions would be problematic within 3-5 years.
|
|
 | 28. | Mont de la Ville (swimming pool and land to South of Fort Regent), St Helier | Screened out in 2012. | - The topology is not suitable for a hospital. Relocation of functions would be problematic within 3-5 years
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
- Significant transport and access issues exist.
|
|
 | 29. | Grainville School, St Saviour | Screened out in 2012. | - Significant transport and access issues exist.
- Relocation of functions would be problematic within 3-5 years.
|
|
 | 30. | Grainville Playing Fields, St Saviour | Screened out in 2012. | - A very large building would be unsuitable to the site setting.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
- Relocation of functions would be problematic within 3-5 years.
|
|
 | 31. | Norman’s Site at Five Oaks, St Saviour | Screened out in 2012. | - Significant transport and access issues exist.
- Ownership and use means availability would be problematic within 3-5 years.
|
|
 | 32. | Fields off Highview Lane, Mont a L’Abbe, St Helier | Screened out in 2012. | - The site footprint is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- A very large building would be unsuitable to the site setting.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
|
 | 33. | Fields adjacent to St Saviour’s Church, St Saviour | Screened out in 2012. | - Significant transport and access issues exist.
- A very large building of 4 – 5 storeys high would be unsuitable to the site setting.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
|
 | 34. | St Andrews Park, St Helier | Screened out in 2012. | - The site footprint is unviable for a hospital with optimal hospital departmental relationship.
- Significant transport and access issues exist.
- A very large building of 5 storeys high would be unsuitable to the site setting.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
|
 | 35. | Fields opposite St Saviour’s School, St Saviour | Screened out in 2012. | - A very large building would be unsuitable to the site setting.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
|
 | 36. | Fields to the North of Five Oaks, St Saviour | Screened out in 2012. | - Significant transport and access issues exist.
- A very large building would be unsuitable to the site setting.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
|
 | 37. | Fields off Trinity Hill, Trinity | Screened out in 2012. | - A very large building would be unsuitable to the site setting.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
 | 38. | Fields off La Grande Route de St Jean, St John | Screened out in 2012. | - A 4 storey building would be required – unsuitable to the site setting.
- Redevelopment would not comply with the Island Plan.
|
|
 | 39. | Peoples Park | Shortlisted in 2015. | - Removed by Council of Ministers prior to States Assembly debate
|
|
 | 40. | Dual Site | Shortlisted in 2015. | - Constrained site compromises hospital design.
- Poor public and emergency access (Overdale)
- Visual and local environmental impact (Overdale).
- Limited opportunity for future expansion (Overdale).
- Long construction period – building around a working hospital (Parade).
- Disruption to patients and staff during construction (Parade).
|
|
 | 41. | Millbrook Playing Fields | Screened out in 2016. | - A covenant may restrict building onsite
- A large building would be unsuitable for the site setting
|